Antioxidants are supposed to be good for us, and most of us try to consume antioxidants through food, drinks or supplements. But ever wonder if one specific form of antioxidant is better than the other? Like, if I love to drink tea, should I drink green, white or black tea? Or, should I cut to the chase and load up on antioxidant supplements?
First, what’s the difference between the teas?
Tea, introduced first as a traditional medicine in Asia, is from the Camellia sinensis plant and can be varied by processing steps: Green tea and white tea are non‐fermented and minimally or lightly oxidized while black tea is fully fermented and fully oxidized. Herbal teas are any teas not made from Camellia sinensis. The different processing results in different bioactive compounds. Green tea has flavan‐3‐ols (catechins), proanthocyanidins (tannins) and flavonols. Black tea contains theaflavins and thearubigins while white tea contains l‐theanine and gamma‐aminobutyric acid (GABA), among others. The health benefit of teas has been correlated with these bioactive compounds, which have anti‐inflammatory, anti‐diabetic and anti‐cancer activities.
Why does it matter that there are different antioxidants? Don’t they all do the same thing?
Antioxidants, produced by the body or ingested, are part of the body’s defense system against damaging free radicals that are formed during the body’s normal cellular processes or when exposed to UV radiation, pollution or stress, etc. Different antioxidants operate in different parts of cells and participate in different chemical processes throughout the body. Some antioxidants suppress the formation of free radicals, while others “scavenge” to remove the free radicals before they do damage, or work to repair damage once it has been done.
Synergy, A theory of the whole is better than the parts
So it makes sense that combining different teas and herbs with various bioactive components might have synergistic (or antagonistic) effects in their bioactive efforts. Synergy is based on the idea that using a whole plant containing a group of chemicals working together or a combination of plants is more beneficial than using a single compound to achieve a specific effect. For example, the equal ratio of of black tea, black pepper (Piper nigrum), ginger (Zingiber officinale) and Holy Basil (Ocimum sanctum) showed higher antioxidant activity compared to that of the individuals. Research on the combination of green and black tea showed a stronger antimicrobial effect than alone.
Tradition in science
So perhaps that synergistic antioxidant and antimicrobial effect is the reason that people in Indonesia and Asia use a mixture of leftover teas to rinse their face. And that is why the JUARA Tamarind Tea Hydrating Toner uses a combination of green, white and black teas for that synergistic antioxidant effect to counteract a day of stress, fatigue and pollution. Oh wait, and I will have a tea with that! Any tea, please!